Wicked For Good.. was it?

SUPER MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD

Trying something new in my life. So, I actually recorded this in the car once I got home from the cinema. No notes, first take, one take - so this as initial of reaction I think you can get. I’m not going to apologise for the stuttering, struggling to get my words out, messing up my words or repeating myself, because I’m a human being and not an AI. I haven’t watched Wicked For Good since, and I won’t be :( I only apologised in the beginning because I feel like Wicked, the cast and fans have been ridiculed quite a lot online and this is in no way to add to that - its just a critique of the storytelling.

If there’s something I said that offends you, remember.. it’s just another perspective. My words here are not law or even fully coherent thought, I am ranting. Just enjoy hearing another perspective.

This is a seven minute preview on an(other) perspective media YouTube Channel but the full episode is exclusive to Love, Builder of Worlds Blog.

Transcript:

Welcome to an(other) perspective, a space where commentary is experiential, where the evidence is existence as one knows it, and therefore also, the lack thereof.
music
Now that I've watched part 2
I have to express my just, disappointment with Wicked
I'm so sorry like
I couldn't be more sorry because, I genuinely feel like
watching Cynthia Erivo perform
and hearing Cynthia Erivo sing has genuinely
like with no exaggeration
given me a new lease on life,
it has really given me something to aspire to.
I would love to be at good as writing
as Cynthia Erivo is at singing and emoting.
Like, her voice gives me like a physical reaction in my body
it is STUNNING and I think her performances across both of the Wicked films
were truly like, they were heartfelt, they were sincere
they were measured, they were- they were deep.. there was like a fountain-
there was a deep well of emotions there.
And I feel like she really pulled from them, and I really got that in the performance
I also feel like it- cinematography
everything it looked absolutely BEAUTIFUL.
It looked SO aesthetically pleasing and-and Paul Tazewell -
my goodness, those costumes were magnificent.

The storytelling does not exist in these two films.
I'm really really really really really really really really sorry.
And it started off with the first film
after you watch the first film in the cinema
and you watch it like two- another
like by the second or the third watch,
you're like huh like..there's not actually much.. that happened here.
But I wanna talk about part 2, because I literally just watched it.

There was a lot of story missing, and by that I'm not saying that they didn't follow the
the play. I'm not saying that um and I did watch the play once when I was a kid, um
the musical and I really enjoyed it
but that- like- the people that I went with to see-
to see the film told me that this
part 2 is in line with what happens in the musical
and what happens on stage
and I was like okay if that's the case then Wicked isn't as great as you guys have been saying
because where is the story?
Where is the drama?
Where? Like where?
What was Elphaba doing all of those months learning magic? Like where was the trying and failing to learn magic?
Where was the depression from the solitude?
Where was her doing her darnedest to convince the animals that - actually - she isn't an opp?
Even though she did do that to uh Chistery and co? She's actually on their side and that's why um Oz and the Wizard of Oz is against her?
Where was that scene?
Where was us, you know, reflecting on her treatment? And reflecting on how actually
while she was being bullied at Shiz, Nessa never showed up for her - and that's why
it was easier for her to make that decision to not return when their father died
do you know what I mean
like even in the year and the- and then that scene
having that scene in there would be um-
would still fit in with the story because guess what Nessa betrayed her- again! EXACTLY, EXACTLY.
where was the-the private reflections of Madame Morrible after every
uh- not after every announcement but at least after one announcement having you know memories of of her and Elphaba bonding?
Where was the- Where was the-
Where was the back and forth? Where was the... what's the word? Where was the duality?
Like.. where was the Judas of it all? Do you know what I mean like, is it me Jesus?
Like is it me ? YEAH! like you were her teacher you like- where were those memories?
Where was like even Madame Morrible maybe she was happy to drop Elphaba in it-Elphaba in it
because she realized how powerful she was
As stated in the first film when she said I can't-I can only read but a few words of the Grimmerie, here comes Elphaba first crack out of the book.
Like where's the memories of her looking at Elphaba "actually
you're actually a little bit too powerful for me and, if I ever need to take you down I will." Like where was that thought? Where was that scene?
Like for Madame Morrible to turn on the dime..?
Why does Madame Morrible hate the fucking a-animals so much? Did an animal kill her mum?
What are we talking about?
And I fucking HATE I hate allegory
I hate allegories for racism for slavery
I- cause you guys you never do it well
that's why I fucking hate robots by Channel 4
I HATE THAT SHIT. It's so fucking racist because there isn't any actual heartfelt- there's like- it you can just tell, the people that are using this allegory
have- they you've like you
like- the marginalisation that black people
and Africans specifically have had to face in the western world
you've never experienced that emotion and you DON'T know how to tell that story.
In the first um film, we should have seen Elphaba trying to assimilate beyond a hair flick like
have you never met a black girl in your life?
it's so ANNOYING. It's so annoying and it's so fucking disappointing, it doesn't make any fucking sense. It doesn't make any fucking sense and d'you know what? Elphaba, maybe she should have come up with a little wig!
She was- she- she- maybe she should have come up with a little straight wig.
Like, as like, and like if we're gonna go there - then let's really go there let's do ASSIMILATION.
Let's do Elphaba acting like she's no longer i-intelligent
acting like Gli-Glinda in that regard as well. Being in class like "oh
what's going on?" do you know what I mean?
Like, let's do fucking assimilation, if we're gonna go then then let's GO.
Let's do- let's do the thing, let's tell the story..

And what is the time frame because as as Elphaba's younger sister
When did- what-what age did Nessa Rose become the governor after her dad died??? What are we talking about?
And speaking of Nessa Rose- give me more give me MORE..GIVE ME MORE.
I feel like one of the things that is missing from the story is
INTENT.
Where was everyone's intent from the apart aside from the fact that she had green skin?
Jealousy, envy- envy is green hello?
let's like, hello?
Hello? Hello?